Early ideas on reincarnation. AI

Deepseek

I am prevented from signing into my Deepseek account on both my cell phone and my laptop. I get the "wheel of death." The result is that I am only able to copy partial conversations.

---

How far back in time can a belief in reincarnation be tracked?

Belief in reincarnation (or transmigration of souls) is one of the most ancient and widespread spiritual concepts in human history. Its origins can be traced back to pre-literate, prehistoric shamanic and animistic traditions, but the earliest clear textual evidence comes from ancient India and ancient Greece.

Here’s a timeline of how far back the belief can be tracked:

1. Prehistoric / Neolithic Era (Before 2000 BCE) – Speculative but Probable

Anthropologists and scholars of religion suggest that beliefs in soul journeying, rebirth, and animal-human spiritual continuity likely existed in hunter-gatherer and early agricultural societies.

Evidence is indirect, based on:

Burial practices suggesting belief in an afterlife.

Shamanic traditions (like those of Siberia, still observed in modern times) involving spirit travel and shape-shifting, which imply fluidity between lives.

No written records, so this remains a scholarly inference from comparative religion and archaeology.

2. Early Textual Evidence – Ancient India (c. 1500–800 BCE)

The earliest clear written references to reincarnation appear in ancient Indian texts.

Vedic Period (c. 1500–500 BCE):

The earliest Hindu scriptures, the Vedas (especially the Rigveda), contain hints of rebirth but focus more on ancestral afterlife.

The concept fully emerges in the later Upanishads (c. 800–500 BCE), where samsara (the cycle of rebirth) and karma (the law of cause and effect across lifetimes) are systematically explained.

Key passages: The Brihadaranyaka Upanishad and Chandogya Upanishad explicitly discuss rebirth based on actions (karma).

This marks the first philosophically developed doctrine of reincarnation in world literature.

3. Ancient Greece (c. 6th Century BCE)

Pythagoras (c. 570–495 BCE) is famously associated with the doctrine of metempsychosis (transmigration of the soul). He and his followers believed the soul was immortal and passed through human, animal, and plant lives.

Plato (427–347 BCE) later formalized these ideas philosophically, especially in dialogues like Phaedo, Meno, and Republic (Myth of Er). Plato argued that souls reincarnate based on their knowledge and virtue.

Some ancient Greek mystery cults (like Orphism) also taught versions of reincarnation.

4. Ancient Celtic and Germanic Traditions (Pre-Christian Era) Classical writers (e.g., Julius Caesar in Gallic Wars) reported that the Druids of Gaul believed in the immortality of the soul and rebirth.

While details are sparse, Celtic and later Norse lore contained ideas of life-after-death continuity, sometimes interpreted as a form of rebirth.

5. Buddhism and Jainism (c. 6th–5th Century BCE) Both traditions emerged in India and inherited and reinterpreted earlier Hindu ideas of rebirth.

Buddha (c. 563–483 BCE) accepted samsara but rejected a permanent self (anatta), teaching rebirth driven by craving and karma without a fixed soul.

Jainism taught that souls (jiva) are bound to cycles of rebirth until they achieve liberation through asceticism.

6. Later Developments

Ancient Egypt: While they had a strong belief in the afterlife, reincarnation per se wasn’t central, though some scholars see traces in texts like the Book of the Dead.

Late Antiquity: Gnostic groups, some Jewish mystics (Kabbalah, later), and early Christian thinkers like Origen entertained ideas of pre-existence or rebirth, though they were later deemed heretical in mainstream Christianity.

Indigenous cultures worldwide (from Siberian shamans to Native American tribes to African traditional religions) often have concepts of ancestral return or cyclical life, documented in more recent ethnography but rooted in ancient oral tradition.

Conclusion: How Far Back?

Textually: Clear, systematic doctrine dates to c. 800–500 BCE in India (Upanishads) and 6th century BCE in Greece (Pythagoras, Orphism).

Culturally/Anthropologically: Beliefs resembling reincarnation likely go back to Neolithic or even Paleolithic times in various forms, though evidence is indirect.

Thus, as a structured religious doctrine, reincarnation is at least ~2,800 years old. As a broader human intuition about the soul’s journey, it may be as old as human spiritual reflection itself.