!!!!!!! Literacy and cognition. AI !!!!!!!!

Grok

1 Changes in cognition induced by literacy

Overview of Literacy's Impact on Cognition

Literacy — the ability to read and write — is one of the most powerful cultural technologies ever invented. It doesn't just add new skills; it profoundly reshapes how the human brain thinks, perceives, and processes information. These changes are observable at neurological, psychological, and cultural levels.

Key Cognitive Changes Induced by Literacy

Shift from Holistic to Analytic Processing

Illiterate individuals process visual stimuli (faces, objects, scenes) more holistically and contextually.

Literate individuals develop a strong bias toward analytic, feature-based processing because reading requires breaking words into letters, phonemes, and grammatical components.

Classic evidence: Studies with illiterate adults in Portugal (1960s–1980s) and more recent work in India (Dehaene, 2010; 2018) show literates are better at ignoring context in mirror-image recognition tasks (e.g., distinguishing “b” from “d”), while illiterates treat mirrored images as identical.

Phonological Awareness and Metalinguistic Awareness

Literacy creates explicit awareness of phonemes (the smallest sound units). Oral cultures rarely segment speech this way.

Example: Illiterate adults struggle with tasks like deleting the first sound from a spoken word (“cat” → “at”), whereas even early readers perform easily (Read et al., 1986; Castro-Caldas et al., 1998). This metalinguistic ability transfers to better verbal memory and logical analysis of language.

Leftward Lateralization and the “Visual Word Form Area” (VWFA)

Learning to read repurposes a specific region in the left occipito-temporal cortex (the VWFA) that, in illiterates, responds preferentially to faces and objects.

fMRI studies comparing literate and illiterate adults from the same villages (Dehaene et al., 2010; 2015) show:

Literates: Strong left-hemisphere dominance for language and visual word recognition.

Illiterates: More bilateral or right-lateralized processing of speech sounds and visual patterns.

Enhanced Verbal Memory and Working Memory

Literate individuals show superior performance on verbal recall tasks (e.g., repeating pseudowords or digit spans) because writing systems give permanent external storage and rehearsal loops.

Evidence: Illiterate Brazilian adults performed worse than their literate siblings on verbal memory tasks, despite identical schooling in other respects (Ardila et al., 2010).

Changes in Logical Reasoning and Categorization

Literacy promotes abstract, decontextualized thinking (Ong, 1982; Goody, 1977; Olson, 1994).

Classic experiments (Luria, 1930s; Scribner & Cole, 1970s among the Vai in Liberia):

Illiterates often answer syllogisms based on empirical knowledge rather than formal logic.

Example:

Q: “In the far north, all bears are white. Novaya Zemlya is in the far north. What color are the bears there?”

Illiterate response (common): “I’ve never been to the far north, so I don’t know.”

Literate response: “White.”

Reduced Sensitivity to Context and Oral-Style Cognition

Oral cultures favor situational, narrative, and formulaic thinking (“the human mind in its untutored state” – Havelock).

Literacy encourages detachment, abstraction, classification, and skepticism toward authority because texts can be scrutinized independently of the speaker.

Plasticity into Adulthood

Strikingly, adults who learn to read late (30–50 years old) still show many of these brain changes within months to years (Dehaene et al., 2010; Skeide et al., 2017). The brain remains highly plastic for reading acquisition.

Summary Table of Major Differences

Domain Typical in Illiterate/Oral Cultures Typical in Literate Individuals

Visual processing

Holistic, context-sensitive

Analytic, detail-oriented

Phonological awareness

Low (speech is unanalyzed stream)

High (explicit segmentation)

Brain lateralization

More bilateral Strongly left-lateralized for language

Logical reasoning

Empirical, situational Formal, decontextualized

Memory strategy

Episodic, formulaic, rhythmic

Verbal labeling, hierarchical organization

Attitude toward statements

Accept based on source authority

Evaluate based on internal consistency

Key Researchers and Landmark Works

Aleksandr Luria (1930s Soviet Uzbekistan expeditions)

Sylvia Scribner & Michael Cole (1970s Vai people, Liberia)

Jack Goody & Ian Watt (1963, 1977)

Walter Ong – Orality and Literacy (1982)

David Olson – The World on Paper (1994)

Stanislas Dehaene – Reading in the Brain (2009); longitudinal adult literacy studies (2010–2020) Bottom Line

Literacy is not just a skill layered on top of an unchanged mind. It is a neurological and cognitive reorganization that favors analysis, abstraction, phonological awareness, and decontextualized logic — often at the cost of some holistic and contextual abilities that dominate oral cultures. The human brain is shaped by its cultural tools, and reading is one of the most transformative tools we have ever invented.